Skip to main content
IDF logo

Consider nurse practitioner or physician assistant for care

November 27, 2023

With the increasing shortage of medical doctors in the United States, making an appointment with a physician can take weeks and even months. If your health matter is urgent, that timeline isn’t practical. Enter an alternative—nurse practitioners (NPs) and physician assistants (PAs). Both types of advanced healthcare practitioners often work alongside doctors and support the physicians with their patient load.

But is it OK to see these types of providers instead of a doctor? What kind of training do they receive? And are they qualified to meet your health needs?

In today’s healthcare climate, PAs and NPs can be acceptable options if a medical doctor is not available in a timely manner, even if you have a primary immunodeficiency (PI).

“It is not necessarily the letters after the person’s name. It is more about the care you are receiving. You want someone who listens and can treat the condition or illness,” said Colleen Brock, a registered nurse and IDF manager of medical programs.

“If you are really sick and you need to be seen, and the doctor has no appointments for months, but the NP or PA can see you next week, then go with one of them. The worst-case scenario is that the NP or PA consults with the doctor about your condition.”

Both an NP and a PA can perform many of the same functions as a physician, such as conducting exams, running tests, diagnosing and treating illnesses, and prescribing medications. However, the two roles require different educational backgrounds, training, and certifications, vary in their approaches to medicine, and diverge when it comes to practicing solo versus under physician supervision.

An NP is an advanced practice registered nurse (APRN) who has completed a bachelor’s of nursing degree, an NP-focused master’s or doctoral degree, and has passed a national NP board certification exam. NPs typically specialize in certain areas, such as family and adult care, acute care, gerontology, oncology, pediatrics, and women’s health.

NPs can act as primary care providers who provide direct care to patients. In 27 states, laws allow them to practice independently from physician oversight. In these states, NPs may evaluate patients, diagnose acute and chronic conditions, order and interpret diagnostic tests, and initiate and manage treatments, including prescribing medications and controlled substances. In the remaining states, they may either work in collaboration with doctors or be supervised by doctors.

NPs follow a nursing framework, and in treating patients, they focus more on how the illness affects the patient’s quality of life, education about healthy lifestyle choices, preventative care, and how best to approach care within a person’s community, culture, or socioeconomic status.

A PA is an advanced practice provider with a master’s degree in physician assistant studies and has also passed board certification. Unlike an NP who specializes in certain patient populations, a PA is typically trained in general medicine.

PAs work in primary care settings interdependently with physicians, and duties may include taking a health history, ordering and interpreting lab and diagnostic tests, prescribing medicine, performing physical exams, and assisting in surgery.

In addition to being available for primary care, PAs and NPs also work in specialist offices. Some patients may see a specialist, such as an immunologist, on their first appointment and then, on follow-ups, see an NP or PA in the practice. If an interaction with an NP or a PA leaves you with more questions, you can always advocate for physician consultation.

“You have the right to say, can you run this past the doctor? Is there any way they can look at notes and double-check and make sure they don't have a second opinion?” explained Brock.

While it’s helpful to have a provider who is familiar with PI, it’s not entirely necessary if they express interest in researching more about the condition.

“What you need more than anything is a provider who is willing to learn and willing to work with immunologists and other specialists,” said Brock.

This page contains general medical and/or legal information that cannot be applied safely to any individual case. Medical and/or legal knowledge and practice can change rapidly. Therefore, this page should not be used as a substitute for professional medical and/or legal advice.